Siding Materials Guide: Vinyl vs Wood vs Metal vs Fiber Cement
Once you've picked a floor plan, one of the biggest decisions left is what goes on the outside of the house. Siding shapes how the home looks for the next few decades, and it also affects your maintenance schedule, your insurance, and how much of your budget is left over for the interior. For owner-builders working from a Home Plan DIY plan set, siding is usually the single biggest exterior line item after the roof, so it's worth understanding the four common options before you order material.
This guide compares vinyl, wood, metal, and fiber cement siding on cost, durability, maintenance, and how easy each one is for a first-time owner-builder to install. None of these numbers replace a local quote, since labor rates, freight, and code requirements vary a lot by region, but they'll give you a realistic starting point for budgeting.
A quick note on where siding fits your overall budget
Total build cost for a Home Plan DIY house typically runs $130 to $220 per heated square foot, depending on your region, finish level, and how much labor you do yourself. On a 1,800 square foot home, that's roughly $234,000 to $396,000 all in. Siding is usually somewhere between 3 and 6 percent of that total, so on the same home you might budget anywhere from $7,000 to $24,000 for exterior cladding depending on the material and how much wall area you're covering.
Vinyl siding
Vinyl is the material most owner-builders start with, and for good reason. Material typically runs $3 to $8 per square foot installed, it comes pre-finished so there's no painting, and it's light enough that two people can install it with basic tools and a rented brake for custom trim pieces. Most vinyl products carry a 30 to 40 year warranty, though real-world lifespan depends heavily on sun exposure and how well it was installed.
The tradeoffs: vinyl can crack in very cold climates if it's hit hard, it can fade over time in intense sun, and cheaper panels sometimes look plasticky up close. It's a strong choice if you're building on a tight budget or want a straightforward DIY install, and it pairs well with simpler traditional and cottage-style plans.
Wood siding
Wood, whether it's cedar lap siding, board and batten, or shiplap, gives a home a warmth that manufactured materials struggle to match, and it's a natural fit for farmhouse and cabin-style plans. Expect to pay $6 to $12 per square foot installed depending on species and profile, cedar and redwood sitting at the higher end because of natural rot resistance.
The catch is upkeep. Wood needs to be stained or painted every 3 to 7 years depending on climate and exposure, and it's more vulnerable to moisture, insects, and rot if it's not detailed correctly at the flashing and end cuts. It's also one of the more forgiving materials for an owner-builder to install and repair in sections, since individual boards can be replaced without redoing a whole wall. If you love the look and don't mind the maintenance rhythm, wood is hard to beat.
Metal siding
Corrugated or standing seam metal siding has become a signature look for modern farmhouse and barndominium plans, and it holds up extremely well in harsh weather. It resists fire, hail, insects, and rot, and a quality steel or aluminum panel can last 40 to 60 years with essentially no maintenance beyond an occasional rinse. Installed cost runs $7 to $14 per square foot, with steel generally cheaper than aluminum or specialty finishes.
Metal does dent if struck hard, it can be noisier in heavy rain unless you add sound-dampening underlayment, and it requires more precise cutting and fastening than vinyl, so budget for a few specialty tools or a subcontractor for the trickier cuts around windows and corners. For rural, mountain, and coastal builds where durability matters more than upfront cost, metal is often the best long-term value.
Fiber cement siding
Fiber cement (often sold under brand names like HardiePlank) is a mix of cement, sand, and cellulose fibers, and it's become the go-to for owner-builders who want a wood look without wood maintenance. It resists fire, rot, insects, and impact better than vinyl or wood, holds paint for 10 to 15 years between coats, and typically carries a 30 to 50 year warranty. Installed cost runs $8 to $14 per square foot.
The downsides are weight and cutting. Fiber cement panels are heavy, usually need two people to handle safely, and cutting them produces silica dust, so you'll want a dust-reducing saw blade and a respirator rather than a standard circular saw setup. It's also less forgiving to install than vinyl, so many owner-builders hire out just the siding crew even when they're doing the rest of the build themselves. If your plan calls for a classic look with minimal long-term upkeep, it's worth the extra install cost.
How to choose for your build
A few questions usually narrow it down fast. If budget and a DIY install matter most, vinyl wins. If you want a natural, characterful look and don't mind repainting every few years, wood is worth it. If your site sees hail, wildfire risk, or heavy weather, metal or fiber cement will save you money in the long run even though they cost more upfront. And if you're matching a specific plan style, like the corrugated metal and cedar accents common on our 1,100 sq ft modern farmhouse plan or the wraparound porch and cedar siding on our 1,932 sq ft modern farmhouse plan, it often makes sense to stick close to what the plan was designed around, since the elevations and trim details are drawn to match.
You can also mix materials. A lot of our most popular plans use board and batten or metal on the gables and a different material on the main walls to control cost while keeping the look the designer intended. Every Home Plan DIY set includes a PDF drawing set plus material list so you can see exactly how much wall area you're covering before you order.
Browse our full collection of house plans to find a design that fits the exterior style, budget, and site conditions you're building for. And if you're comparing farmhouse-specific options, our modern farmhouse house plans guide covers cost and features in more depth.
Frequently asked questions
What's the cheapest siding option for an owner-builder?
Vinyl is typically the least expensive both in material cost and labor, since it's light, comes pre-finished, and doesn't require special tools to install.
Which siding lasts the longest?
Metal and fiber cement both commonly carry 40 to 50 year warranties and hold up better than vinyl or wood against fire, hail, and insects, though actual lifespan depends on climate and installation quality.
Can I mix siding materials on one house?
Yes, and many plans are designed to do exactly that, using a secondary material like metal or board and batten on gables or accent walls to control cost while adding visual interest.
Do I need special tools to install fiber cement siding myself?
You'll want a saw with a dust-reducing blade and a proper respirator because of the silica dust it creates when cut, plus a second person to handle the panels safely. Many owner-builders do the rest of the exterior themselves and hire out just the siding install.
Does my house plan already account for siding cost?
Your Home Plan DIY drawing set gives you the wall dimensions and elevations you need to calculate exact material quantities, but siding is priced separately from the plan itself since the material choice is up to you.